Skip to main content

The Railway Police as Witnesses: 1939

 

At a hearing of the North London Juvenile Court in early 1939 the Chairman told the court that “railway police evidence is proverbially unreliable”.  The case involved two boys charged with causing damage to property belonging to the London Midland and Scottish Railway (LMS).  We do not know the outcome of the case or the details of alleged offence. 

The comments from the bench caused outrage.  Police Review ran a piece by Jack Hayes, their Parliamentary Correspondent, which decried the comments and suggested that they …”make an invidious distinction between the railway police and the regular police”.  He describes the difficult duties that fall to the railway police and ends by saying:  “I have always found the railway police good fellows, courteous and obliging, attentive to their duties, and with these qualities they are as good as anyone else as witnesses in a court of law”.

Fifty years later I recall a BTP officer making an application for a warrant at the Guildhall Justice Rooms in the City of London.  The Chairman of the bench asked if there was a ‘normal’ police officer who could be sworn to support the information as he was not content with the evidence of a ‘railway policeman’.  The officer politely declined the suggestion and withdraw the information. He walked over to Clerkenwell Magistrates Court and obtained the warrant under the hand of the Stipendiary (a District Judge in modern terms).

Back in 1939 the Chairman of the Juvenile Bench did withdraw his comments and apologise.  This might have been connected with the fact that although the LMS was the victim, the prosecution was mounted by, and the police witnesses were from, the Metropolitan Police.

Jack HAYES (1887-1941), the outraged author of the parliamentary column in Police Review was a former Member of Parliament.  He had been General Secretary of the National Union of Police and Prison Officers after resigning from the Metropolitan Police in which he had served as a sergeant.  The Union was effectively banned in 1919.  He was the first ex police officer to sit in the House of Commons.  

 

Phil Trendall

January 2024

 

NOTES

 

Police Review 24 March 1939 p 278

 

Jack Hayes:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jack_Hayes_(politician)  


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why Do Non Home Department Police Forces Get Missed When Legislation is Being Drafted

  WHY DO NON HOME DEPARTMENT POLICE FORCES GET MISSED WHEN LEGISLATION IS BEING DRAFTED? Note: The Home Department is the traditional name for the Home Office and the Home Secretary is technically the Secretary of State for the Home Department.   In this and other pieces I tend to use the titles interchangeably.   I hope that by confusing my readers I can distract them from the boring nature of the blog itself.   One part of my work lies in the field of research.   This is not well paid and is a somewhat lonely pastime, but I do enjoy the thrill of tracking down information in archives, dusty corners of the internet and guiding people around bits of London. I find that there is often an overlap between the past and present, indeed life is a continuum.    The present is a product of the past.   The influence of what has come before is often apparent in what is done today. Frequently to understand the modern operating context we have to get pa...
Post a Comment
Read more

GWR Police and the Local Magistrates 1839

  Fig One:  Copy of Letter to the Reading Justices found in the correspondance of the Home Secretary 183 9 Last week I was at the National Archives working on some papers relating to an RAF Bomb Disposal Flight during the Second World War.   Naturally I found myself reading the Home Secretary’s correspondence file for 1839.   These research leaps will be very familiar to those who spend time in archives and libraries.   I have (mostly) given up researching the history of the railway police but it is hard to resist the temptation of surfing a catalogue and ordering a few extra files to pad out the task in hand.   On this occasion I found myself reading letters that had been sent to Lord John Russell (1) and in particular a of a letter sent by the Great Western Railway to the Justices of the Peace in Reading which had been copied to the Home Secretary. Fig Two:  Lord John Russell (1792-1878): later The Earl Russell.  Photo 1861. The early days of ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Second World War 3: A Letter From a Cocked hat

                                       LNER Police Dog Handlers Carrying Revolvers at Hull 1941 (Photo BTPHG) Stories get passed down from generation to generation and often get changed on the way.   Often though, when the evidence is examined, our valued stories are found to be gross distortions of what actually happened.   I was therefore rather pleased recently to have one of these tales of Railway, Dock and Canal (RDC) policing to be fully based in fact. In 2011/12 I led   the project to re-introduce armed policing to BTP.   It was a challenging task that required attention to lots of different issues – not least the need to get the law changed to allow BTP officers to have firearms at all.   The project left me with an interest into the history of armed policing and in the legal position of the RDC police forces. T...
Post a Comment
Read more